I often search in Google Maps the village where my grandpa came from, deep in rural Poland. I look at the few houses and try to imagine which one was his. Then I go to the nearest town and look for the Jewish cemetery, or what's left of it. Is his family there? Did somebody bury the ashes? "Ida" is personal.
Every shot a picture. Literally. I feel that space is similar to Lucrecia Martel's treatment in "The Headless Woman", where anything left out speaks volumes. Some reviewers note that this virtuosity can act as a distraction. Instead of losing yourself in the movie, we react to shots as they formally are, parts of an art piece. When we watch Welles flex his genius muscles in "Kane", we marvel at the inventiveness but we are not taken out of the enchantment. But given the current state of cinema we are perhaps happy enough to have something pretty to look at. Hey, at least Pawlikowski took the time to try! The photographic aspect alone deserves a re-watch.
Not to speak about the big issue that shall not be discussed in Poland, the treatment of Jews not by the Nazis but by neighbors. I'm not going to write about it here. I know, they know, we know. It was done everywhere, also in the "advanced" countries in the West. I must say though, that I find Ida's situation depressing. If she doesn't have children, her line will have dissapeared from history, and the Nazis would have won. Maybe that's the point of the movie.
Should you watch "Ida"? Yes. Is it boring? Only if you don't engage with it.
Thursday, August 22, 2024
Tuesday, August 20, 2024
Bodies: regarding sickness, image and beauty. Don Hertzfeldt, The House is Black,
"Lenox Hill" (2020) is a reality series from Netflix where we follow a group of neurosurgeons and their attempts to save the lives of patients that suffer from different kinds of brain cancers. Why am I suggesting this? Because I just watched Don Hertzfeldt's excellent "It's Such a Beautiful Day" (2011), part three of the "Bill Trilogy", the story of a man with a sickness that is never named, but that could undoubtedly be one of the hopeful Lenox Hill souls. The trilogy is composed by three animated shorts that make a single story, so I recommend you all to watch it in its entirety. The Netflix series and Hertzfeldt's fantasy complement each other quite well, since you get to experience both sides of something that affects the core of the self.
"Looks That Kill" (2020, Kellen Moore) is a Young Adult fantasy about a boy that has a face so beautiful that can kill people, thus must hide it with bandages. He befriends a plain looking girl with health problems. Both of them supposedly want the opposite sex to pursue them because of their personalities. Instead of wasting one hour and a half in this hypocritical hogwash, you could try to understand what changed Che Guevara's life when he visited a leper colony. Lepers are people with a very evident condition that produces rejection upon view. The best Persian poet of the 20th Century, Forough Farrokhzad, directed a short film that shone light into the unwanted ("The House is Black"). Like Tod Browning before ("Freaks"), Farrokhzad finds the human behind the sickness and poverty and validates their existance. Here they are, not represented by a commercial machine in search of marginal gains but in their own flesh.
TSPDT 2020 ranking : 332
Wednesday, August 7, 2024
"Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World" (2023), Radu Jude.
A modern masterpiece. This movie is a comedic journey through the maladies of the new twenties. It is a scattershot approach to systemic criticism but it works quite well by covering many bases. Are the problems presented just Third World Problems? No, the developed countries impose their will. Why is there no revolt by the Third World victims then? Because they must flow with the system to get the scraps. Was it better before, in communist times? It seems not, Ceaușescu was a totalitarian dictator. The film is dense with references, jokes and commentary, and will probably remain as a time capsule for future cinephiles and historians.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)